7 Most Stubborn Dog Breeds and How to Train Them

7 Most Stubborn Dog Breeds and How to Train Them

Reviewed by Dr. Veronica Heller, Veterinarian  ·  Published 2026-10-12  ·  Last Updated 2026-10-28

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Popular with dog owners: Treat Pouch · Dog Stairs · Puzzle Toys

In my veterinary practice, I frequently hear exhausted owners complain that their dog is simply too ‘stubborn’ to learn. From a clinical perspective, I rarely see a truly defiant dog; instead, I see a breakdown in communication.

What we label as stubbornness is almost always a mismatch of breed motivation, human expectations, and training style. Understanding your dog’s biological drives is the medical and behavioral key to unlocking their cooperation.

If you are struggling with an independent breed, you are not alone. Let’s look at the science of canine behavior to transform your training journey.

Redefining ‘Stubbornness’ through a Clinical Lens

When clients tell me their dog is stubborn, I explain the behavioral concept of operant conditioning. Dogs do not experience human spite or malice; they simply perform behaviors that are reinforcing to them.

If a command does not offer a clear reward, an independent breed will choose a more lucrative option.

We must shift our perspective from demanding blind obedience to negotiating partnerships based on breed-specific motivations. I always tell my clients that training is not about dominance, but about clear communication.

In my years treating dogs, I have found that behavior is a vital sign of health. Sometimes, what looks like stubbornness is actually hidden pain or orthopedic discomfort.

• Use high-value, species-appropriate rewards like freeze-dried meat
• Keep training sessions short, ideally under 5 minutes
• End every session on a positive, successful note
• Never use physical punishment, which destroys trust instantly

The Siberian Husky: The Independent Escapologist

Siberian Huskies were bred to run long distances and make survival decisions independent of their mushers. If a Husky sees an open gate, their predatory drive and desire for freedom override any basic recall cue.

In my practice, I frequently treat escape-related injuries from Huskies who bypassed secure fencing simply because they were bored. Training them requires high-value currency, like real boiled chicken or freeze-dried beef liver, delivered with absolute consistency.

They are also highly vocal and will express their discontent openly. Do not argue with your Husky; instead, reward the quiet moments of focus.

• Provide high-intensity physical exercise daily to curb boredom
• Use secure, escape-proof harnesses for walks
• Introduce interactive puzzle toys to challenge their intellect
• Practice recall in safe, enclosed spaces before attempting outdoors

Preventing the Great Escape

Huskies are master escapologists who can climb, dig, or chew through standard enclosures. I advise my clients to install secure, tall fencing that extends at least one foot underground to prevent tunneling.

A minimum height of six feet is required to prevent athletic leaps, and locks must be escape-proof.

The Beagle: The Nose-Guided Explorer

Beagles are scent hounds, meaning their olfactory cortex is exceptionally large and highly developed. When a Beagle catches a scent trail, their brain virtually shuts down auditory processing to focus on the smell.

They are not actively ignoring your recall command; they literally do not hear you over the chemical data flood.

To successfully train a Beagle, you must integrate their nose into the reward system rather than fighting against it. Using scent-tracking games as a reward for obedience is a highly effective clinical tool.

If you try to use harsh corrections, they will shut down or search for a way to escape the pressure. Positive, reward-based methods are the only way to build a lasting connection with a hound.

• Use smelly treats like wet food, salmon, or liver paste
• Practice recall indoors with zero distractions first
• Allow ‘scenting breaks’ as a reward for polite loose-leash walking
• Never let a Beagle off-leash in an unfenced, unsecured area

Channeling the Olfactory Drive

To prevent your Beagle from pulling you down the street, dedicate the first ten minutes of your walk to sniffing. Use a cue like ‘go sniff’ to let them know when they are allowed to explore, then transition to structured walking.

The English Bulldog: The Low-Energy Negotiator

The English Bulldog is physically powerful, low in stamina, and highly prone to heat exhaustion. Because they suffer from brachycephalic airway syndrome, they will actively refuse to move if they feel physically uncomfortable or tired.

Force-based training or prolonged exertion can trigger a life-threatening respiratory crisis in this breed. Keep sessions short, fun, and cool, and never drag a resisting Bulldog by their neck.

Instead of pulling back, use gentle guidance and high-value treats to lure them forward. Patience is your greatest tool when working with their unique physical limitations.

• Train exclusively in air-conditioned environments during summer
• Use a wide, supportive Y-harness instead of a neck collar
• Reward with tiny, low-calorie treats to prevent unhealthy weight gain
• Stop immediately if you hear loud rasping or heavy wheezing

Managing Respiratory Limitations

Because of their short faces, Bulldogs can overheat in minutes, even in mild weather. I recommend keeping training sessions restricted to 3-5 minutes, with cool water readily available.

Stop immediately if you observe heavy panting or foaming at the mouth.

The Dachshund: The Tenacious Underground Hunter

Dachshunds were bred to hunt badgers in dark, narrow subterranean burrows. This dangerous work required immense bravery, independent decision-making, and an absolute refusal to back down.

When your Dachshund refuses to come inside on a rainy day, that is their ancestral tenacity speaking.

In the clinic, I also must protect these dogs from Intervertebral Disc Disease (IVDD). Their long spines are highly vulnerable to injury, which must dictate how we train them.

A stubborn Dachshund might be hesitating because a movement hurts their back. Always have your vet evaluate any sudden refusal to perform basic cues like sitting or down.

• Install ramps next to furniture to prevent high-impact jumps
• Keep their weight managed strictly to reduce spinal strain
• Use supportive harness-based leash attachments exclusively
• Support their entire body when lifting or carrying them

Spinal Protection Protocols

Never use training techniques that require jumping up, standing on hind legs, or leaping off furniture. I recommend teaching ‘ramp compliance’ early using positive reinforcement so they avoid high-impact jumps that compress the spine.

The Jack Russell Terrier: The Hyper-Focused Strategist

Jack Russells possess an intense, high-energy drive that can easily look like defiant stubbornness. They are highly intelligent problem solvers who do not tolerate repetitive, boring training drills.

If you do not give them a constructive job, they will invent one, which usually involves destroying your drywall.

To train a Jack Russell, you must keep their mind engaged with complex, fast-paced puzzle work and physical outlets. They respond beautifully to agility training and clicker training.

They are also highly prey-driven, so working on a reliable ‘leave it’ command is critical for their safety. Consistent, positive training will help channel their immense energy productively.

• Use a clicker to capture precise, fast-paced behaviors
• Introduce interactive puzzle toys for daily mental stimulation
• Vary training locations to keep their busy minds guessing
• Incorporate structured play, like fetch, as a primary reward

Combating Boredom Destructiveness

Jack Russells will quickly turn to destructive chewing or digging if training is too repetitive. I recommend introducing scent work or agility hurdles to keep their high-energy minds occupied.

A tired Jack Russell is a well-behaved Jack Russell.

The Afghan Hound: The Aloof Aristocrat

Afghan Hounds are ancient sighthounds bred to hunt large game across vast desert terrains. They are highly independent, emotionally sensitive, and lack the natural desire to please humans that retrievers possess.

Harsh corrections will cause an Afghan Hound to shut down completely and withdraw from you. They require quiet, gentle training environments and an abundance of patience.

I advise my clients to view training an Afghan Hound more like building a partnership with a cat.

If you try to force them into compliance, you will only break their trust and create a fearful pet. Respect their independent nature and reward every small step of cooperation.

Related: How to Stop Counter Surfing in Dogs

The Shiba Inu: The Cat-Like Autonomist

The Shiba Inu is famous for its clean, cat-like nature and fierce personal autonomy. They value their personal space and will only cooperate if they see a clear, immediate benefit to doing so.

In my clinical experience, Shibas are the most likely breed to throw a dramatic ‘Shiba Scream’ when handled improperly. Early cooperative care training is an absolute necessity to ensure safe veterinary visits throughout their lives.

They do not tolerate physical manipulation, so lure-and-reward training is the gold standard for this breed. Once a Shiba trusts you, their loyalty and intelligence are unparalleled.

• Desensitize them early to paw handling, nail clippers, and restraint
• Use high-value, novel treats like freeze-dried minnows
• Keep handling sessions extremely positive, short, and respectful
• Never force compliance, as this can trigger fear-based aggression

Mastering the Shiba Scream

If a Shiba feels cornered or forced during nail trims, they may emit an intense, high-pitched vocalization. I advise owners to step back, reduce pressure, and reward calm behaviors with high-value treats rather than forcing them through the procedure.

The Vet’s Golden Rules for Training Independent Breeds

Regardless of the breed, there are clinical training rules that apply across the board. Stubbornness is simply a label we use when we fail to understand a dog’s motivation.

By using high-value rewards, keeping training sessions short, and understanding breed-specific drives, we can overcome any communication barrier. Your veterinary team is always here to help you distinguish between behavior issues and underlying medical pain.

Remember that consistency is the foundation of all successful canine training. If you change the rules daily, even the most biddable breed will become confused and frustrated.

Related Dog Guides

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources & Further Reading

• American Kennel Club (AKC)
• American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA)
• Merck Veterinary Manual

Final Thoughts

Training a so-called stubborn dog is one of the most rewarding journeys a pet owner can undertake. It forces us to grow as communicators and to truly understand the beautiful diversity of the canine mind.

If you are struggling, please remember to rule out pain or underlying medical issues with your vet first.

With patience, consistency, and the right high-value motivators, even the most independent breed can become a joyful, cooperative partner. Do not give up on your independent dog; their brilliant mind is worth the effort.

You Might Also Like

Explore More